Thursday, April 25, 2013

The Age of Reason

                Before starting The Age of Reason, I read the editor’s acknowledgements. He thanks Kim and Jonah for “patiently listening to many Paineful hours of me thinking aloud.” Upon reading that, I was expecting a text that would be very Paineful. However, although it is definitely not my favorite text we have read in class, I did not think it was as terrible as I had expected.
                Although I found some sections dull and uninteresting, like when he goes on and on about the solar system, I do think he has thought-provoking ideas. Yes, he criticizes religion, especially Christianity, going so far as to reference “the stupid Bible of the church that teaches nothing.” I can understand how Paine’s criticism may offend readers that are very religious and involved with the church. However, I think one of Paine’s most important ideas is that of rationality. I think it is okay to be very religious, but also that it is good to question your beliefs. I really liked Thomas Jefferson’s words to Peter Carr, where he says “Your own reason is the only oracle given you by heaven.” I agreed with someone in class today who posed the concern of people blindly following a religion. It seems that some people are raised to adopt their parents’ morals, beliefs, and religious attitudes. There is nothing wrong with this, but I do think questioning organized religion may be useful for everyone to do, and perhaps doing so would bring someone even closer to their religion or their perceived God. 
                I feel that Temple suggests that we read this text as part of Mosaics class because it provides an alternative viewpoint than did the previous works, Genesis and the Daodejing. Those texts were not critical of religion, and instead proposed ways of faith that are important to consider. Reading each of those texts makes us more knowledgeable about beliefs that we may have not been aware of before. Similarly, The Age of Reason shows us a different side to ideas that were touched upon in Genesis. It is essential to consider all aspects of a situation; something we discussed while reading Socrates. Along the same lines, it seems like we have in class experts on the texts not only to get class discussion started and to overview the day’s text, but also to show that there can be an advocate and a critic on the same topic, and that both of those opinions are valid and worthwhile. Being in Mosaics class this semester has taught me the value in observing both sides of an argument or idea. It has also shown me that many texts have lacunas or issues with edits/translations, but it is important to look past them to understand the bigger picture. The bigger picture is not always clear, and perhaps changes after each text we read, but nevertheless, I have learned a great deal through each text we’ve read this semester.

 

Thursday, April 18, 2013

Genesis

                When I first saw that Genesis was a required reading, I was not sure what to think. It seemed like the most religious text among the list of works we would read throughout the semester, which to me felt a little out of place. However, having read Genesis, I believe that it fits in quite well with the assortment of works we have read thus far.
                First, I couldn’t help but notice while reading that there were a lot of notes throughout the text, which were explained at the bottom of each page. The majority of these notes were translations. I often found myself frustrated because some of these translations did not seem useful. For example, on page 22, the text says: “And the Lord stood beside him” (28:13). The note at the bottom says: “Or stood above it.” Perhaps this difference in translation is unnecessary in understanding the essence of the text. However, the translations make me more aware of the fact that the stories of Genesis have been edited and printed in different editions or versions. Like Gilgamesh and the Daodejing, these various translations, although similar, could change the reader’s perspective of the work depending on which translation they read. Sometimes the various translations of a work could make it seem less credible, since so many people have pored over it word for word, but I do think that it is important to take into consideration here that these stories of Genesis have been edited, compiled, and translated. In this way, it is similar to other works we have read; I think it is important to recognize the essence of each text despite varying translations or lacunas as seen in Gilgamesh. The translation and compilation of a text shows not only how far back the text dates, but it makes us question why so many versions exist and how each version affects the work.
                Secondly, I think we read Genesis because of its cultural roots. Although it has many tales of incest, rape, sibling disputes, jealousy, and favoring of sons, at its core it is a basis for several religions. I feel as though sometimes the Bible may be thought of only in regards to Christianity, especially some of the later parts that we did not read. However, Genesis is important for everyone to read because it is an origin story for many popular religions including Judaism and Islam. I also think that it fits well with other texts we have read because it increases our awareness of other cultures and time periods. I would say that it was nice to read Genesis right after the Daodejing because the two are similar in that they explore culture and society, yet they come from very different backgrounds. Although each text is distinctly different from the next, they all fit together in an appropriate, mosaic-type way. The essence of the class is not to read works that all stem from the same time period and geographical region. Each work we have read not only teaches us about the history of a given time, but also allows us to form our own opinions about past cultures and their presence in society today. The point is to read about a multitude of subjects and take a little meaning from each one—then we will walk away with our own cultural mosaics. 

Thursday, April 11, 2013

The Daodejing of Laozi

               Although I do not completely follow or understand everything presented in the Daodejing, I see the importance of the text and why we must read it at Temple. In class today, we talked about the fact that the Daodejing critiques greed and the effects greed has on humans.  On page 60, the Daodejing mentions living without desires and that “the people simplify their own lives.” To me, this quote connects to today’s society in that we tend to be very materialistic creatures who love to consume and collect.  The idea of simplifying one’s life likely seems impossible to Americans because we grow up surrounded by so many items, objects, and pressure to work and be proactive. The idea of simplifying seems possible only if we abandon our current daily routines and perhaps relocate to a remote area where nature blossoms. At least that’s how I felt while reading the Daodejing. I agree with Professor Lowe that it is fitting to read the Daodejing in springtime when the weather is nice and it seems possible to relax and be at peace. However, I’m not sure we can relinquish all of our material possessions and daily routines in order to find true peace or find the Way.

                Currently I am in a World Music and Cultures class and we are learning about Asian music. The other day we learned about Japanese music and the principle of ma, which emphasizes time and space. Space is created in music, art, and architecture so that the space can be filled with personal meaning or energy. This principle connects to chapter eleven of the Daodejing, which says: “By carving out doors and windows we make a room. But only by relying on what is not there, do we have use of the room.” This quotation is important because it forces us to think in a way we usually do not; space is essential and emptiness is not akin to less. The professor showed us a few pictures of household rooms utilizing the principle of ma. The rooms had no clutter, and the few items in the room held significant value (were not excessive or plentiful). To me, this is living simply. Living simply does not need to mean living with no possessions or blank walls. It means keeping what is important and minimizing excessive desires. The Daodejing urges humans to live simply without an excess of desires.
                In chapter 5 of The Souls of Black Folk, Du Bois tells the story of Atalanta to caution Americans about the evils of falling prey to golden apples. He points out that wealth was being used to cure social ills, and that oftentimes wealth was not the proper solution to those issues. In my Souls of Black Folk blog, I asserted that we read Souls of Black Folk partly to absorb Du Bois’ caution of greed and how it harms society. I would say that a main reason why we read the Daodejing is also to be reminded that greed and excessive desires can cause harm and that it is possible to live fully in the absence of material items. Of course, it is also important to read the Daodejing because it makes us aware of a culture we may have never learned of otherwise. Although we may never come close to finding the Way, the Daodejing is a useful text to read because it causes us to question our daily lives and wonder if we too could live simply.

Tuesday, April 2, 2013

The Souls of Black Folk

                I think Temple wants us to read the Souls of Black Folk for several different reasons. First, it presents a history of slavery, as well as issues of race and diversity. Issues of race and diversity are still prevalent in today’s society; we talked in class today about Temple being a diverse university, even though it may be predominantly white. Perhaps universities in general have a larger proportion of white students due to problems in the education system. The article Being White in Philly touches on the issue of attendance and graduation rates in predominantly black schools and areas. Similarly to the Souls of Black Folk, the article suggests the presence of a color line that separates Temple from its surrounding communities, and also whites from blacks.

                To me, it seems that it has been conditioned in our society that students must go directly to college after graduating from high school. A problem with this is that some students do not recognize the importance of a college education and mistake college as just something they have to do before they can enter the “real world.” The Souls of Black Folk highlights W.E.B. Du Bois’ assertion of the importance of higher education, and I believe that we are required to read this work in order to gain perspective on the importance of college. Du Bois said that without higher education, teachers cannot be trained to teach the common-schools, and thus no learning would come to fruition. Until reading Du Bois’ work, I thought that the education system evolved in a linear fashion, starting with common-schools and then later progressing to colleges. He shows how the education system revolves around higher education; I felt this was an interesting perspective and made me appreciate my own pursuit of higher education somewhat more.
                Similar to the Trials of Socrates, the Souls of Black Folk shows different sides of an argument. In chapter 3, Du Bois critiques Booker T. Washington’s program, saying that Washington created a paradox that makes it impossible for the Negroes to succeed. Du Bois does include that many people, both black and white, respected Washington and his plan to increase industrial training, economic development, and civic inferiority. This detail made me think more about Du Bois’ point of view in comparison to Washington’s, and also about how someone can gain respect for promoting a plan that on the surface alienates a large percentage of the population. The Trials of Socrates also gave different perspectives on the same central idea; I think we read both the Trials of Socrates and the Souls of Black Folk because it is essential that we be able to identify and evaluate all sides of a story or central idea.
                One other point that Du Bois makes that I feel is pertinent to our society today is the idea that society is greedy. In chapter 5, Du Bois tells the story of Atalanta, who fell prey to the golden apples that were in her path. Paralleling Atalanta, Du Bois cautions readers against falling prey to the golden apples of society, namely wealth and greed. On page 84, Du Bois asserts that wealth is used to cure social ills, where it may not be the best solution to the problem.  On the same note, Du Bois mentions that the burden of the Negro problem belongs to everyone and that no hands are clean unless wrongs are righted. Today, the burden of societal and cultural problems does belong to everyone, but is it possible to right the wrongs that still occur today?

Wednesday, March 20, 2013

The Trials of Socrates

             In class we discussed several possible reasons of why Temple wants us to read the Trials of Socrates. We mentioned the system of justice still prevalent in today’s society, in that doing something unjust to someone who has wronged you in unacceptable. Also, the text is historically old and full of pertinent themes.
Another reason of why we must read this text is that the Socratic Method is still used today. I did a little research on ways the Socratic Method is used in today’s society to see if I could gain more insight into its practical applications. I found that the Socratic Method is often used in law school to get students to think about both sides of a court case. Additionally, classroom teachers use the Socratic Method to provoke thinking in their students. Socratic question is integrated into some forms of psychotherapy because it helps patients gain insight. I was surprised to learn that some companies utilize the Socratic Method when training in the human resource department because it helps employees to think in various ways. Although we did not study the mechanisms of the Socratic Method, it is important to realize that these techniques are used in a multitude of professions and ways today. Reading about Socrates now can help us to identify and gain more from the Socratic Method if we come across it in the future.
 I believe that we read the Trials of Socrates because it presents different views of the same character, Socrates. If we were only to read one of the sections, we would have a very different understanding and perception of Socrates.  Plato was a student of Socrates and admired his work. Because of this, Plato’s text perhaps portrays Socrates in a more positive way. In the Apology, it is revealed that Socrates is willing to die in order to show his beliefs. Xenophon’s account focuses on Socrates’ defense to the jury. Like Plato’s account, it does not cast a negative light on Socrates. Unlike the Apology, it highlights the idea that Socrates defiance in front of the jury is intentional and thus strengthens his position. Xenophon’s introduction says, “Socrates is tired of living and wants to force the jury to sentence him to death” (177). This quote presents an opposing view of Socrates’ intentions than does Plato’s account. The Clouds portrays Socrates in a more comical way that causes readers to question Socrates and what he is really about. In the Clouds, there is criticism of science and religion in that Socrates teaches the belief of clouds instead of the gods and Zeus. This section poses even more questions to the reader about who Socrates really was and if knowledge brings fulfillment or corruption.
Reading the texts of Plato, Aristophanes, and Xenophon does leave the reader with many questions that may not be answerable. However, in life it is important to understand all sides of an issue or topic before coming to a conclusion. I believe that is why we read the Trials of Socrates. Had we just read the Clouds, we would not fully understand Socrates and his defense. Reading all of the texts allows us to be more informed, which arguably brings fulfillment and not corruption. Knowledge may corrupt in some instances, such as with Strepsiades and his son Pheidippides, but I would argue that having multiple perspectives on a topic minimizes corruption.

Friday, March 15, 2013

Marianne Moore's Living Room at the Rosenbach

                I have been to the Rosenbach Museum and Library twice so far, and was impressed both times. I went to view Marianne Moore’s living room. My first visit was part of a Hands- on- Tour of the living room and included the ability to see letters Moore had written and received.  I was amazed at the level of detail in the room and how similar the recreated living room was in comparison to the picture of her original living room in Greenwich Village. The furniture, books, photographs, window space, fireplace, typewriter, and even chin-up bar were in the exact same places as her original living room. The fact that most impressed me was that Moore filed away newspaper clippings in the books on her bookshelf; the Rosenbach has each clipping archived. Also in the living room are several animal knick knacks and figurines. Interestingly, the Rosenbach has incorporated Moore’s animal figurines and plates into the dining room display of the Rosenbach brothers’ house.

Moore's living room at the Rosenbach

                Moore’s living room was used as a workplace and also to entertain guests. The room is decorated to fulfill both purposes; I can see how she would like to work by the fireplace during the day and then host visitors by the fireplace at night. The room is not enormous, which gives it an intimate feel. I was surprised to learn that the reason Moore’s living room is part of the Rosenbach collection is partly because of her popularity as a 20th century American poet, but also due to her correspondence with James Joyce and Maurice Sendak. Moore and Sendak were actually neighbors in New York, and because the Rosenbach housed Sendak’s collection (and Joyce’s), she had a greater incentive to have her belongings there as well. Furthermore, Moore was a Pennsylvania native, but did not know the Rosenbach brothers nor live in Philadelphia. She attended Bryn Mawr college, which perhaps was the closest to Philadelphia Moore came. It fascinates me that Moore’s personal living room and belongings have become a staple in the Rosenbach Museum and Library despite the fact that Moore never crossed paths with the Rosenbach brothers.
                The staff at the Rosenbach Museum and Library was extremely accommodating and helpful during both of my visits. When they learned that I was there to do research for a school assignment, they gave me the business card of the librarian so she could further assist me in my research should I need it. During my second visit, I went on a general tour of the Rosenbach brothers’ house. The tour was given by docent Farrar Fitzgerald, who was eager to help—and knows Professor Lowe! Both tours gave me a better idea of the work of the Rosenbach brothers and of Moore, and I am beginning to understand why Moore’s collection is part of the Rosenbach collection. I have a lot more research to do, especially involving a scandal with a former Rosenbach director, but I can see that Moore’s living room at the Rosenbach speaks to the viewer and tells her story in a way no other display could. I would argue that although the Rosenbach brothers never met Marianne Moore and she did not have a strong connection to Philadelphia, her collection should remain part of the Rosenbach Museum and Library.

Thursday, February 28, 2013

Borderlands/ La Frontera

                Although Borderlands/ La Frontera is not one of my favorite books we have read in class thus far, I do think that Gloria Anzaldúa’s message is very well conveyed and that this text is an essential component of Mosaics. 

                Anzaldúa’s main point is that she does not feel like a whole self. She identifies several dualities that she faces in her life, especially those of gender and ethnicity. Anzaldúa sees herself as mestiza, meaning she is a mix of European and Native American descent, and also as Chicana, meaning her background is Mexican but she was born in the United States (Texas). Anzaldúa struggles with her different cultures and expresses this struggle in Borderlands by incorporating passages written in Spanish. Some readers feel as though her use of Spanish alienates readers who do not understand Spanish, and that it causes a disconnect between Anzaldúa and the message she wants to convey. However, her inclusion of Spanish perhaps enriches the illustration of her struggles. For a non-Spanish speaking reader, it is difficult to comprehend sections of the book and likely makes the reader frustrated. Anzaldúa’s conflict of cultures, as well as her conflict with sexuality, leads her to feel isolated.
                I really liked the point that was brought up in class today about Anzaldúa creating as many borders as she breaks down. She does break down borders of sexuality, self, others, and ethnicity, but also seems to heighten the alienation she feels. On page 25, she defines the purpose of borders as: “to define the places that are safe and unsafe, to distinguish us from them.” It seems that Anzaldúa accepts the concept of borders and also the distinguishing between cultures. When talking about art, she makes a clear distinction between the art of Native Americans and the art of Westerners. If Anzaldúa breaks down borders of sexuality and self, why does she seem to accept borders relating to her culture?
                Also on page 25, Anzaldúa refers to a borderland as being in a constant state of transition. This definition fits very well with her work toward becoming a whole self. Anzaldúa likely utilizes writing as a way to become more herself. About her writing pros, she says that writing brings forth images from her unconscious. These images are related to traumas during her lifetime, and that reconstructing those images helps her make sense of them and ultimately helps to heal her. The process of writing in itself is characterized by growth and transition from one idea to another. Anzaldúa refers to her “awakened dreams” as shifts and metamorphoses of thought, reality, and gender; by thinking of those dualities as transitional, Anzaldúa gains more insight into herself and also the world she lives in.
                Today’s class brought up Anzaldúa’s concept of self and how she seems to define it in three different ways: as marked by experiences and what meaning you take from them, as defined by the people you associate with, and as defined by your culture. Although her definitions seem disconnected, and perhaps suggest a lack of identity or acceptance of too many identities, I think that she wants to convey the notion that the self is very complex. Furthermore, there is no one way to think of oneself; the self is transitional and constantly shifts. Thus, it makes sense that Anzaldúa would have a complex, shifting conception of self. Anzaldúa’s presentation of self and the dualities and struggles faced when trying to define oneself and grow into a whole self is relatable to us today. Because of the complexities it presents, Borderlands/ La Frontera is important for everyone to read.