Wednesday, March 20, 2013

The Trials of Socrates

             In class we discussed several possible reasons of why Temple wants us to read the Trials of Socrates. We mentioned the system of justice still prevalent in today’s society, in that doing something unjust to someone who has wronged you in unacceptable. Also, the text is historically old and full of pertinent themes.
Another reason of why we must read this text is that the Socratic Method is still used today. I did a little research on ways the Socratic Method is used in today’s society to see if I could gain more insight into its practical applications. I found that the Socratic Method is often used in law school to get students to think about both sides of a court case. Additionally, classroom teachers use the Socratic Method to provoke thinking in their students. Socratic question is integrated into some forms of psychotherapy because it helps patients gain insight. I was surprised to learn that some companies utilize the Socratic Method when training in the human resource department because it helps employees to think in various ways. Although we did not study the mechanisms of the Socratic Method, it is important to realize that these techniques are used in a multitude of professions and ways today. Reading about Socrates now can help us to identify and gain more from the Socratic Method if we come across it in the future.
 I believe that we read the Trials of Socrates because it presents different views of the same character, Socrates. If we were only to read one of the sections, we would have a very different understanding and perception of Socrates.  Plato was a student of Socrates and admired his work. Because of this, Plato’s text perhaps portrays Socrates in a more positive way. In the Apology, it is revealed that Socrates is willing to die in order to show his beliefs. Xenophon’s account focuses on Socrates’ defense to the jury. Like Plato’s account, it does not cast a negative light on Socrates. Unlike the Apology, it highlights the idea that Socrates defiance in front of the jury is intentional and thus strengthens his position. Xenophon’s introduction says, “Socrates is tired of living and wants to force the jury to sentence him to death” (177). This quote presents an opposing view of Socrates’ intentions than does Plato’s account. The Clouds portrays Socrates in a more comical way that causes readers to question Socrates and what he is really about. In the Clouds, there is criticism of science and religion in that Socrates teaches the belief of clouds instead of the gods and Zeus. This section poses even more questions to the reader about who Socrates really was and if knowledge brings fulfillment or corruption.
Reading the texts of Plato, Aristophanes, and Xenophon does leave the reader with many questions that may not be answerable. However, in life it is important to understand all sides of an issue or topic before coming to a conclusion. I believe that is why we read the Trials of Socrates. Had we just read the Clouds, we would not fully understand Socrates and his defense. Reading all of the texts allows us to be more informed, which arguably brings fulfillment and not corruption. Knowledge may corrupt in some instances, such as with Strepsiades and his son Pheidippides, but I would argue that having multiple perspectives on a topic minimizes corruption.

Friday, March 15, 2013

Marianne Moore's Living Room at the Rosenbach

                I have been to the Rosenbach Museum and Library twice so far, and was impressed both times. I went to view Marianne Moore’s living room. My first visit was part of a Hands- on- Tour of the living room and included the ability to see letters Moore had written and received.  I was amazed at the level of detail in the room and how similar the recreated living room was in comparison to the picture of her original living room in Greenwich Village. The furniture, books, photographs, window space, fireplace, typewriter, and even chin-up bar were in the exact same places as her original living room. The fact that most impressed me was that Moore filed away newspaper clippings in the books on her bookshelf; the Rosenbach has each clipping archived. Also in the living room are several animal knick knacks and figurines. Interestingly, the Rosenbach has incorporated Moore’s animal figurines and plates into the dining room display of the Rosenbach brothers’ house.

Moore's living room at the Rosenbach

                Moore’s living room was used as a workplace and also to entertain guests. The room is decorated to fulfill both purposes; I can see how she would like to work by the fireplace during the day and then host visitors by the fireplace at night. The room is not enormous, which gives it an intimate feel. I was surprised to learn that the reason Moore’s living room is part of the Rosenbach collection is partly because of her popularity as a 20th century American poet, but also due to her correspondence with James Joyce and Maurice Sendak. Moore and Sendak were actually neighbors in New York, and because the Rosenbach housed Sendak’s collection (and Joyce’s), she had a greater incentive to have her belongings there as well. Furthermore, Moore was a Pennsylvania native, but did not know the Rosenbach brothers nor live in Philadelphia. She attended Bryn Mawr college, which perhaps was the closest to Philadelphia Moore came. It fascinates me that Moore’s personal living room and belongings have become a staple in the Rosenbach Museum and Library despite the fact that Moore never crossed paths with the Rosenbach brothers.
                The staff at the Rosenbach Museum and Library was extremely accommodating and helpful during both of my visits. When they learned that I was there to do research for a school assignment, they gave me the business card of the librarian so she could further assist me in my research should I need it. During my second visit, I went on a general tour of the Rosenbach brothers’ house. The tour was given by docent Farrar Fitzgerald, who was eager to help—and knows Professor Lowe! Both tours gave me a better idea of the work of the Rosenbach brothers and of Moore, and I am beginning to understand why Moore’s collection is part of the Rosenbach collection. I have a lot more research to do, especially involving a scandal with a former Rosenbach director, but I can see that Moore’s living room at the Rosenbach speaks to the viewer and tells her story in a way no other display could. I would argue that although the Rosenbach brothers never met Marianne Moore and she did not have a strong connection to Philadelphia, her collection should remain part of the Rosenbach Museum and Library.