One
reason why Freud is still prevalent in today’s society, and why we have to read
his lectures, is that humans can relate to many of his assertions. The Oedipus
complex definitely has truthful aspects; many boys see their mothers as
love-objects because the mother is the first woman they see and interact with. Critics
of the Oedipus may assert that boys do not wish to have sex with their mothers
and certainly do not want to kill their fathers. Again, here is where I think
some people focus too much on the extreme elements of Freud’s statements and
thus fail to absorb the key components. The main component of the Oedipus
complex is that boys are drawn to their mothers and girls to their fathers.
One other aspect of Freud’s work that is
prevalent today is the way children dream and think. On page 394, Freud
explains how children exemplify sexual interest by questioning the origin of
babies. He goes on to say that a child who is about to welcome a new sibling
has egoistic fears and feels lonely as a result of being “defrauded of the
truth by grown-ups.” Readers may not believe that a child has egoistic fears or
that grown-ups make their children feel lonely, but there is truth in Freud’s
assertion here. He says that a child first believes that a baby comes as a
result of eating some certain food. I enjoyed reading this section because
recently, I was babysitting and the five-year old girl asked me where babies
come from. I was caught off guard by this and the first thing I thought to say
was the good old story of the stork. When she pressed further, she asked: “Does
a baby come when mommy eats a lot of food?” I thought that was so entertaining,
and in reading Freud, I realize that her question, my reaction, and her connection
between pregnancy and food are all very common occurrences. Another common occurrence
that people may criticize is Freud’s concept of children being sexual, especially
in relation with their genitalia. I do not like to think of children as sexual,
and I see that Freud really means to say “pleasure seeking.” It is true that
children explore their genitalia; I have witnessed that during naptime at the
preschool where I worked. A few boys would have their hands in that area as
they relaxed and prepared to nap. Teachers would tell them to stop moving and
lay still—I now see that as an element of the societal repression that is put
on children who are innocently just exploring themselves or relaxing. At times,
Freud comes off as extreme and almost ridiculous in his assertions, but there
is definitely an element of truth to his theories that even his critics must
take into consideration.
Parapraxes,
too, are Freudian concepts that directly apply to our lives today. We all
experience slips of the tongue and forget what we were just going to say. Freud’s
lecture on dreams as wish-fulfillment is believable because we can see that
many of our dreams fulfill actions we hope to occur. Freud critics may declare
that dream censorship does not relate directly to some sexual impulse as Freud
suggests, but it is important to understand the more basic notions of Freud’s
ideas before harshly criticizing him. His biggest criticism is that he relates
everything back to sex, but isn’t that what we do in our society today? Phrases
like “sex sells” are popular in the media, and our society puts a lot of
emphasis and even pressure on the topic of sex. Freud’s ideas about sex were
very radical for his time, but are they so radical today?