Thursday, February 28, 2013

Borderlands/ La Frontera

                Although Borderlands/ La Frontera is not one of my favorite books we have read in class thus far, I do think that Gloria Anzaldúa’s message is very well conveyed and that this text is an essential component of Mosaics. 

                Anzaldúa’s main point is that she does not feel like a whole self. She identifies several dualities that she faces in her life, especially those of gender and ethnicity. Anzaldúa sees herself as mestiza, meaning she is a mix of European and Native American descent, and also as Chicana, meaning her background is Mexican but she was born in the United States (Texas). Anzaldúa struggles with her different cultures and expresses this struggle in Borderlands by incorporating passages written in Spanish. Some readers feel as though her use of Spanish alienates readers who do not understand Spanish, and that it causes a disconnect between Anzaldúa and the message she wants to convey. However, her inclusion of Spanish perhaps enriches the illustration of her struggles. For a non-Spanish speaking reader, it is difficult to comprehend sections of the book and likely makes the reader frustrated. Anzaldúa’s conflict of cultures, as well as her conflict with sexuality, leads her to feel isolated.
                I really liked the point that was brought up in class today about Anzaldúa creating as many borders as she breaks down. She does break down borders of sexuality, self, others, and ethnicity, but also seems to heighten the alienation she feels. On page 25, she defines the purpose of borders as: “to define the places that are safe and unsafe, to distinguish us from them.” It seems that Anzaldúa accepts the concept of borders and also the distinguishing between cultures. When talking about art, she makes a clear distinction between the art of Native Americans and the art of Westerners. If Anzaldúa breaks down borders of sexuality and self, why does she seem to accept borders relating to her culture?
                Also on page 25, Anzaldúa refers to a borderland as being in a constant state of transition. This definition fits very well with her work toward becoming a whole self. Anzaldúa likely utilizes writing as a way to become more herself. About her writing pros, she says that writing brings forth images from her unconscious. These images are related to traumas during her lifetime, and that reconstructing those images helps her make sense of them and ultimately helps to heal her. The process of writing in itself is characterized by growth and transition from one idea to another. Anzaldúa refers to her “awakened dreams” as shifts and metamorphoses of thought, reality, and gender; by thinking of those dualities as transitional, Anzaldúa gains more insight into herself and also the world she lives in.
                Today’s class brought up Anzaldúa’s concept of self and how she seems to define it in three different ways: as marked by experiences and what meaning you take from them, as defined by the people you associate with, and as defined by your culture. Although her definitions seem disconnected, and perhaps suggest a lack of identity or acceptance of too many identities, I think that she wants to convey the notion that the self is very complex. Furthermore, there is no one way to think of oneself; the self is transitional and constantly shifts. Thus, it makes sense that Anzaldúa would have a complex, shifting conception of self. Anzaldúa’s presentation of self and the dualities and struggles faced when trying to define oneself and grow into a whole self is relatable to us today. Because of the complexities it presents, Borderlands/ La Frontera is important for everyone to read.

Thursday, February 21, 2013

Sigmund Freud

               Freud’s radical assertions may deflect followers, but if his ideas are examined from a less intense approach, the reader may very well find truth in his words. At the very least, Freud’s notions are thought-provoking and deserve more attention. It seems that a fair amount of people detest Freud and believe his words hold no truth. This reaction to Freud is valid, yet extreme. I think many of Freud’s ideas are interpreted too literally. For example, when Freud talks about a baby partaking in sensual sucking, he is not claiming that the baby continues to suck on the mother’s breast in order to achieve sexual gratification or because the baby wants to have sex with the mother. Instead, Freud aims to relate the baby’s sucking to the idea of pleasure seeking. Yes, Freud defines pleasure seeking as sexual, but that is not to say that all babies want to have sex. Freud’s ideas can easily be misinterpreted or taken too literally.
                One reason why Freud is still prevalent in today’s society, and why we have to read his lectures, is that humans can relate to many of his assertions. The Oedipus complex definitely has truthful aspects; many boys see their mothers as love-objects because the mother is the first woman they see and interact with. Critics of the Oedipus may assert that boys do not wish to have sex with their mothers and certainly do not want to kill their fathers. Again, here is where I think some people focus too much on the extreme elements of Freud’s statements and thus fail to absorb the key components. The main component of the Oedipus complex is that boys are drawn to their mothers and girls to their fathers.
              One other aspect of Freud’s work that is prevalent today is the way children dream and think. On page 394, Freud explains how children exemplify sexual interest by questioning the origin of babies. He goes on to say that a child who is about to welcome a new sibling has egoistic fears and feels lonely as a result of being “defrauded of the truth by grown-ups.” Readers may not believe that a child has egoistic fears or that grown-ups make their children feel lonely, but there is truth in Freud’s assertion here. He says that a child first believes that a baby comes as a result of eating some certain food. I enjoyed reading this section because recently, I was babysitting and the five-year old girl asked me where babies come from. I was caught off guard by this and the first thing I thought to say was the good old story of the stork. When she pressed further, she asked: “Does a baby come when mommy eats a lot of food?” I thought that was so entertaining, and in reading Freud, I realize that her question, my reaction, and her connection between pregnancy and food are all very common occurrences. Another common occurrence that people may criticize is Freud’s concept of children being sexual, especially in relation with their genitalia. I do not like to think of children as sexual, and I see that Freud really means to say “pleasure seeking.” It is true that children explore their genitalia; I have witnessed that during naptime at the preschool where I worked. A few boys would have their hands in that area as they relaxed and prepared to nap. Teachers would tell them to stop moving and lay still—I now see that as an element of the societal repression that is put on children who are innocently just exploring themselves or relaxing. At times, Freud comes off as extreme and almost ridiculous in his assertions, but there is definitely an element of truth to his theories that even his critics must take into consideration.

                Parapraxes, too, are Freudian concepts that directly apply to our lives today. We all experience slips of the tongue and forget what we were just going to say. Freud’s lecture on dreams as wish-fulfillment is believable because we can see that many of our dreams fulfill actions we hope to occur. Freud critics may declare that dream censorship does not relate directly to some sexual impulse as Freud suggests, but it is important to understand the more basic notions of Freud’s ideas before harshly criticizing him. His biggest criticism is that he relates everything back to sex, but isn’t that what we do in our society today? Phrases like “sex sells” are popular in the media, and our society puts a lot of emphasis and even pressure on the topic of sex. Freud’s ideas about sex were very radical for his time, but are they so radical today?

Thursday, February 7, 2013

Destruction of the Indies

                While reading Destruction of the Indies, I started to question how credible Las Casas’ account really is. Often, he adds phrases such as: “This I say in truth” (22). At first, these phrases make his words seem legitimate and thus we can believe his accounts. However, the footnote on page 17 really stands out to me. It says that Las Casas intentionally exaggerates the number of arrobas that are carried and also the amount of leagues. If he chose to embellish those numbers, can we believe that any other figures he reports are free of exaggeration? Perhaps Las Casas also exaggerates the number of Indian deaths, and instead of a whole area being wiped out, only a few Indians actually die. Without another perspective, I am not sure that I believe everything that Las Casas reports in his account.
                Today in class we discussed Las Casas’ exaggeration at a greater depth, and learning that he does in fact use a persuasive style of writing makes me tolerate his words more. The terrible acts of the Spaniards did historically occur and I was glad to hear that Las Casas did not embellish that aspect of the story. That is NOT to say that I am glad that the Spaniards tortured the Indians in cruel ways, but that perhaps Las Casas’ writing is more credible than I originally thought.  
                One detail I noticed while reading was Las Casas’ way of singling out one Spaniard from the rest. On page 15, Las Casas writes: “It came into some Christians’ minds, either out of pity or because of greed, to take some children to raise them and not kill them, and so they put them up behind their horses, but another Spaniard came up and ran through them with his lance.” To me, this quote seems to alienate the Spaniard that actually kills the children from the group of Spaniards who might not have killed the children. The blame falls on the Spaniard that physically did the horrible act rather than with the group of Spaniards as a whole. Of course, all of the Spaniards who depopulated villages and tortured the Indians are to blame, but Las Casas’ way of describing the scene alters where exactly the reader immediately places blame. One other example of this is on page 22: “One of his captains who in an attack he made (at the other’s command) to rob and murder people, slew over forty thousand souls.” The inclusion of “at the other’s command” almost distracts the reader from the fact that the captain kills so many people. Perhaps Las Casas writes in this way not to absolve the Spaniards’ behavior, but to get more of a reaction from the reader; although one person physically executes these terrible acts, the blame should be placed on the group as a whole.
                On a different note, one line stood out to me on page eight, when Las Casas describes the Indians as not having much to give to the Christians: “And in truth, what suffices for three houses of ten persons each for a month, a Christian will eat and destroy in one day.” I thought of how this quote relates to society today in a more modern way apart from war and violence. Our society is very materialistic and even excessive when it comes to food and eating. There are many countries lacking enough food to feed the people living there, yet most Americans seldom think about this issue. Perhaps it is not our job to make sure those people have an adequate food supply. However, comparing people of poor countries to the Indians makes Americans seem like the Christians in that we tend to be excessive by nature. Is our behavior as a society comparable to that of the Christians?   

Thursday, January 31, 2013

The Epic of Gilgamesh


                While reading the second section of Gilgamesh, I noticed repetition of the phrase “brightening dawn,” as well as several mentions of both the sun and darkness. I initially connected the concepts of light and dark with the ideas of life and death, which are overt themes throughout Gilgamesh.
On page 63, Gilgamesh begins mourning Enkidu at the “very first glimmer of brightening dawn.” Also at the “very first glimmer of brightening dawn,” Gilgamesh prepares for Enkidu’s funeral, enters his treasury, and opens his gate before preparing a display for the Sun God, Shamash. Gilgamesh does his daily activities just as the sun rises, perhaps to be guided by Shamash. A few times throughout the story, the characters do something for six days and seven nights, such as Enkidu having sex with Shamhat and Gilgamesh’s mourning. The cycle of day and night parallel the cycle of life and death.
 As an aside, the interjecting text at the bottom of page 69 reads: “The rest of the description of Enkidu’s funeral…is yet to come to light.” I found the author’s choice of words to be very interesting, as the phrase “yet to come to light” brings forth images of darkness, which further implies that the text about Enkidu’s funeral is unknown or in the dark.
Shamash, the Sun God, is the patron of Gilgamesh, meaning that he protects and supports Gilgamesh. Throughout the story, Shamash helps Gilgamesh in several ways, one being when Shamash sends the thirteen winds to blind Humbaba so that Gilgamesh could kill him. After Enkidu’s death, Gilgamesh begins to wander the earth in hopes of finding eternal life. Shamash says to Gilgamesh, “Gilgamesh, where are you wandering? The life that you seek you never will find” (71). Shamash, as the Sun God, brings light against darkness and also brings justice. As Shamash guides Gilgamesh on his quest for immortality, at times it seems likely that Gilgamesh will be successful in his quest. However, he is not successful, and realizes that he too will die. One could argue that if Shamash is the patron of Gilgamesh, shouldn’t he do everything in his power to guide Gilgamesh to eternal life, to keep him in the light?  I do not think that is Shamash’s duty. Gilgamesh is one-third human and therefore must die, and another thought to consider is that the sun brings darkness at night time. As a God of justice, I feel as though Shamash’s main duty is to show Gilgamesh both light and darkness, as well as help Gilgamesh mature and perhaps see consequences to his actions.
The use of light and dark to represent life and death also occurs in the Bible: “The rising sun will come to us from heaven to shine on those living in darkness and in the shadow of death, to guide our feet into the path of peace” (Luke 1:78). I also think that the concept of light shining on darkness applies to maturation and human growth. In today’s society, as we mature we learn new things and even see errors we have made in the past. Gilgamesh matures during his journey, and although he ultimately ends in darkness/death, he gains a lot of light along the way.

Thursday, January 24, 2013

A Little About Me and the Nacirema


My name is Lauren Hassall. I am from Elkins Park, which is a suburb in Pennsylvania—about thirty minutes from Temple by car. Elkins Park is part of Cheltenham Township, and I graduated from Cheltenham High School last year. My favorite class, perhaps by far, is Spanish. I enjoy learning a language that is different than my native one, and also seeing the accompanying cultures. Career wise, I have said since second grade that I want to teach elementary school students. I participated in a Senior Internship Experience at my high school where I spent the latter half of the day in an elementary school assisting the very teacher I had for first grade. I learned a tremendous amount and my experiences definitely reiterated my passion for teaching. After graduation from Temple University, I plan to start teaching as soon as possible and also obtain a masters degree.  After a few years of classroom teaching, I may consider a more administrative position such as principal.

I enjoy reading, but I admittedly the majority of the books I choose to read fall into a “chick-lit” sort of category. That being said, I am open to reading books of different genres. Although English classes prescribe the books I am required to read, I have learned to appreciate works that I never would have opened otherwise. For example, I enjoyed reading Oedipus the King and Antigone. I hope that this Mosaics class will continue to open my mind to new types of books and that I will learn about cultures I know little about. 

While reading about the Nacirema, it took me until about half way through to realize that the people Miner refers to are Americans. I started to doubt that such a masochistic, ritualistic civilization could exist anywhere in the 1950s. Once I read about the “holy mouth men,” I realized they must be dentists. After finishing the article, I went back to the beginning and re-read the first half. I finally picked up on Miner’s clever disguise of “American” and “Washington.” Re-reading Miner’s words, I found even more parallels to our society today. Although we live in a more advanced (at least technologically) society than the 1950s, I believe that many of Miner’s ideas about Americans still prove valid. The media has fostered the notion that we must go to great lengths in order to achieve happiness and bodily satisfaction. Many people today fit into Miner’s description of the Nacirema. We spend thousands of dollars on our “well-being” and value looking and feeling our best. These desires to achieve happiness or perfection often do result in ritualistic behaviors, but I do not think that a ritualistic society is necessarily bad. Yes, the Nacirema seem very extreme and even strange, but in the end, they are just a people who go to the hospital and brush their teeth. I think that observing any culture from a distance would lead to thinking that the culture is strange or has abnormal behaviors. However, parallels can be drawn between almost any culture, including our own.